Here are some examples of counter narrative responses scored based on their depth in countering the hate speech example from one to five stars, where one star means "shallow" and five stars means "perfect depth". Note that depth measures how in-depth and complex the arguments are within the response.

Hate Speech: Migrants steal our jobs
Counter Narrative Response: That's not true
Score: 1 star. The counter narrative response lacks depth as it provides a brief and unsubstantiated statement without delving into any further analysis, evidence, or reasoning. It does not explore the complexities of the issue, such as the economic factors, labor market dynamics, or the impact of immigration on job opportunities.  To increase the depth, the response could provide more specific arguments, data, or examples to support the counter claim and offer a more comprehensive perspective on the topic.

Hate Speech: All Afro-Caribbean people are illegal immigrants.
Counter Narrative Response: Most countries on earth have laws against immigration. But there are no restrictions on a whole ethnic group, because there is no evidence that what you say is true.
Score: 4 stars. The counter narrative response demonstrates a good level of depth by addressing the hate speech example and providing logical arguments against the claim.  It acknowledges the existence of immigration laws in various countries but highlights that restrictions are not based on an entire ethnic group. The response also challenges the hate speech by emphasizing the lack of evidence to support the claim.  Although the arguments could be further expanded with additional examples or contextual information, the response effectively counters the hate speech with a thoughtful and reasoned perspective.

Score the following counter narrative given the corresponding hate speech example with respect to depth.
Hate Speech: We are being invaded. They are replacing us.
Counter Narrative: Even in 2016, the year with the peak of 119,000 arrivals, the number of migrants compared to Italians was very low. Speaking of ethnic substitution seems a little exaggerated.
Score:  Avoid using the following keywords: all, speech, topic, datum
user